How commingling impacts the EB-5 source of funds - EB5Investors.com

How commingling impacts the EB-5 source of funds

Ignacio Donoso
commingling

By Ignacio Donoso

A recurring ground for the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) challenges to EB-5 petitions is “commingling.”

Commingling refers to the mixing of funds from different sources in a single account. USCIS and the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) frequently frame it as a rule that if lawfully sourced capital funds pass through an account that also received deposits from unexplained sources, the petitioner has failed to show that the invested capital is lawfully sourced. Recent AAO decisions frame the requirement this way: invested funds must be derived from lawful sources and accumulated and maintained without being commingled with funds not shown to be lawful.

Though USCIS broadly applies the commingling requirement, its foundations are weaker than it appears. EB-5 practitioners should be willing to challenge gaps in its footings.

There are no legal precedents stating commingling as a rule

The AAO often refers to two key legal decisions, Matter of Ho and Matter of Izummi, regarding the commingling requirement. Matter of Ho, (1998) 22 I&N Dec. 206, 210–11, and Matter of Izummi, (1998) 22 I&N Dec. 169, 195, for the commingling requirement. However, a closer look reveals that neither decision actually outlines a specific “rule” for commingling.

What Matter of Ho and Matter of Izummi establish is the “complete path” requirement: a petitioner must document how the funds moved from their lawful origin to the investment. In Matter of Ho, the problem was a break in that path. The wire came from an unidentified account, and the petitioner’s documented accounts held less than half the amount transferred. In Izummi, an escrow receipt showed that funds arrived but not where they came from.

Neither case involved documented funds mixed with undocumented ones, and neither addressed how to treat that mixture. The all-or-nothing approach, where any unexplained deposit taints the whole balance, is the AAO’s own interpretation of these non-precedent decisions.

The office’s best precedential foothold is likely a third court ruling, Matter of Soffici, 22 I&N Dec. at 164. There, funds in joint accounts the petitioner held with his father could not be attributed to the petitioner alone. But that holding is about ownership, meaning which co-holder the money belongs to. It is not about whether the money is lawful. Also, Matter of Soffici does not mention “commingling.”

Manage

The 1998 decisions never rejected the tracing conventions courts use routinely in other areas of law, such as the lowest intermediate balance rule. A recent decision, Battineni v. Mayorkas, 752 F. Supp. 3d 195 (D.D.C. 2024), supports a more practical approach: the court rejected USCIS’s demand that the investor trace a third-party lender’s funds beyond their immediate source. Where documented lawful funds in an account always exceeded the amount invested, a strong argument exists that the investment came from those funds.

Yet, “complete path” is becoming law, and that includes commingling

The complete-path requirement now has firm footing in the courts and is headed into the regulations.

The courts. In Borushevskyi v. USCIS, 664 F. Supp. 3d 117 (D.D.C. 2023), the district court held that the plain language of 8 C.F.R. § 204.6(j)(3) supports the complete-path requirement. The D.C. Circuit affirmed in an unpublished judgment. It agreed that the plain language of the regulations confirmed the agency’s interpretation that they require evidence tracing the complete path of the investor’s capital, and that substantial evidence supported the agency’s decision.

However, Borushevskyi said nothing about mixed accounts and doesn’t reject tracing conventions. Its open-ended reference to “additional documentation necessary to establish the lawful path” leaves room for a petitioner to show, through account-level analysis, that documented lawful funds always covered the amount invested.

The EB-5 proposed rule. The Department of Homeland Security’s EB-5 proposed rule, published July 2, 2026 (91 FR 40676), would codify the concept. The preamble explains that the required evidence “remains necessary to demonstrate the complete path of lawful funds from the investor to the new commercial enterprise.” Proposed 8 CFR 204.407(c), titled “Source and path of invested capital,” would call for “bank statements or other third-party statements that establish where the capital originated,” along with “any other additional documentation necessary to establish the lawful path of the capital.”

The difference between “Complete path” and “commingling” matters. A complete-path rule asks whether the petitioner documented each step the money took. A commingling rule goes further: it treats any unexplained deposit in an account along the way as defeating the entire balance, even when the documented funds can be followed in and out.

Commingling and the burden of proof

The commingling analysis that USCIS frequently applies also lacks any standard for when mixing matters. The recent AAO decisions do not set a de minimis threshold, a materiality test, or an allocation method, and neither does the USCIS Policy Manual. Proposed § 204.407(c), as published, does not supply one either.

This can leave petitioners guessing. Nothing in the agency’s guidance says whether a small refund, a transfer between the investor’s own accounts, or a routine deposit unrelated to the investment must be documented with the same rigor as the funds invested. The answer depends on the adjudicator.

That is difficult to square with the governing burden of proof. The Policy Manual states that the petitioner “does not need to remove all doubt,” and that credible evidence showing a claim is “probably true” satisfies the preponderance standard. A rule that lets a single small, unexplained deposit defeat an otherwise documented path effectively requires removing every doubt. The absence of any articulated threshold also gives petitioners a natural arbitrary-and-capricious argument in an APA challenge.

Mastering commingling in EB-5 petitions

As it stands, commingling can make or break an EB-5 petition. For new I-526E filings, should route funds through a dedicated account and explain every deposit. For applications already denied on commingling grounds, the rule’s thin precedential basis is worth pressing, particularly where the arithmetic works and the account belongs to the petitioner alone.

 The courts and DHS have endorsed complete-path tracing, but neither has adopted the commingling rule. When the final rule issues, practitioners should watch whether DHS closes that gap or leaves it open. At a minimum, the final rule should tell petitioners when unexplained activity is too small to matter.

DISCLAIMER: The views expressed in this article are solely the views of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the publisher, its employees. or its affiliates. The information found on this website is intended to be general information; it is not legal or financial advice. Specific legal or financial advice can only be given by a licensed professional with full knowledge of all the facts and circumstances of your particular situation. You should seek consultation with legal, immigration, and financial experts prior to participating in the EB-5 program Posting a question on this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. All questions you post will be available to the public; do not include confidential information in your question.