I am buying an apartment building in Seattle from a seller who came to the U.S. via the EB-5 program and who currently has a conditional green card. He claimed that his conditional green card makes him a “non-foreign” person for FIRPTA purposes, and that I do not have to withhold anything for FIRPTA. Is this correct? What happens if he fails to obtain a permanent green card? Could I be held liable retroactively for the FIRPTA taxation?
Answers
Bernard P Wolfsdorf
Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration AttorneyThe first step is to determine if that transferor is a foreign person or not. Here is the review: Is he or she a U.S. citizen or a resident alien by meeting one of the following? Lawful permanent resident (green card holder), substantial presence test? It appears he or she is a lawful permanent resident since a conditional green card holder is treated the same as a green card holder for all purposes. While some treaties may allow a person to be resident in more than one country, it is unlikely this person is not a resident.
Fredrick W Voigtmann
Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration AttorneyYou should consult with a tax expert since issues regarding tax liability are complex and often are very case-specific or person-specific. In general, a conditional lawful permanent resident has the same rights, privileges, duties and responsibilities as a permanent resident.
Salvatore Picataggio
Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration AttorneyThis really highlights the importance of a team of professionals for a business or investment based immigration process. As an immigration attorney, I can't really speak to FIRPTA, but I definitely know a few specialists in that area who I would bring in to help!
Charles Foster
Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration AttorneyThe seller, who has conditional lawful permanent residency, would be deemed to be a non-foreign person for FIRPTA purposes. While it is highly unlikely that he will fail to obtain a permanent green card given the very high approval rate for I-829 petitions to remove conditions, you should not be held liable for the FIRPTA taxation if at the time of the transaction he was a non-foreign person.
A Olusanjo Omoniyi
Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration AttorneyYes, the seller is correct. He is currently a conditional permanent resident. Even assuming he later fails to obtain a permanent residency (permanent green card), the sale as a conditional permanent resident stands. Based on experience, the buyer could never be held retroactively liable.
Lynne Feldman
Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration AttorneyConditional residents are permanent residents for most purposes.
Jinhee Wilde
Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration AttorneyA conditional resident is still a permanent resident and could do everything that U.S. citizens could do except vote. Thus, he is not a foreign person at this time of your transaction.
DISCLAIMER: the information found on this website is intended to be general information; it is not legal or financial advice. Specific legal or financial advice can only be given by a licensed professional with full knowledge of all the facts and circumstances of your particular situation. You should seek consultation with legal, immigration, and financial experts prior to participating in the EB-5 program. Posting a question on this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. All questions you post will be available to the public: do not include confidential information in your question.