How could the new rules of inadmissibility on public charge grounds impact our I-829 case? - EB5Investors.com

How could the new rules of inadmissibility on public charge grounds impact our I-829 case?

We are about to file our I-829 petition. Recently we heard that those who have received certain types of public benefits would be defined as “public charges” and will be deemed inadmissible. We also learned that the scope of public benefits under question might extend to certain tax credits and Medicare programs. We used some tax credits during our conditional permanent residency period, but we thought it was our right to do so and we did not expect that this could backfire. Could this impact our I-829 case? What should we do now?

Answers

Charles Foster

Charles Foster

Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration Attorney
Answered on

It is doubtful that the use of tax credit through your conditional permanent residency period will have any adverse effect on your ability to remove conditions. Remember, you are already a lawful permanent resident in the United States. When you file your petition Form I-829 to remove conditions, the total focus is whether or not you complied with your commitments in your EB-5 petition Form I-526 to make the required investment and to create the required number of jobs. Furthermore, tax credit and Medicare would not be the type of public charge that would result in you being deemed to be a public charge. Again, you have already acquired your permanent residency.

Bernard P Wolfsdorf

Bernard P Wolfsdorf

Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration Attorney
Answered on

The final rule has not yet been published, but the general idea is to create an extended lookback period. DHS proposes reviewing the previous 36 months of benefit use. This lookback period is markedly different from current public charge determinations, which are exclusively prospective. In the new rule, DHS put forward that it will continue making public charge inadmissibility determinations within the context of an immigrant&#39s overall situation, referred to as the "totality of circumstances" test. The test includes consideration of: age, health, family status, assets, resources, financial status, education and skills. A required affidavit of support from a sponsor DHS proposes codifying the totality of circumstances test by using a weighted evaluation system that compiles "positive factors" and "negative factors" to determine whether an immigrant is a public charge. It is not clear your use of tax credits and Medicare programs will bar you as there are numerous factors to evaluate. An EB-5 applicant should generally not have a problem.

Salvatore Picataggio

Salvatore Picataggio

Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration Attorney
Answered on

There hasn&#39t been much guidance, if any, on which "public benefits" would and would not affect immigration processes. Hopefully any such penalties will be prospective rather than retroactive.

Julia Roussinova

Julia Roussinova

Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration Attorney
Answered on

The proposed rules are not in effect at this time and it is unlikely they will apply to current pending cases retroactively.

BoBi Ahn

BoBi Ahn

Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration Attorney
Answered on

Tax credits are not a part of the proposed changes in "public charge grounds". Also, the provision has not been implemented yet, so no changes as yet. Public charge would include receipt of public benefits, including cash assistance for income maintenance, Medicaid, Medicare Part D for low-income subsidy, food stamps, public housing, etc.

A Olusanjo Omoniyi

A Olusanjo Omoniyi

Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration Attorney
Answered on

The proposed new rules of inadmissibility won&#39t affect any of the pending I-829 cases, including yours, because those rules cannot be retroactively applied.

Marko Issever

Marko Issever

EB-5 Broker Dealers
Answered on

Please check the USCIS website. Before being alarmed, please spend a few minutes and read DHS Proposed Rule and how it applies to your particular situation. You might be pleasantly surprised that in your particular case, the benefits you availed yourself to are not included in public charge inadmissibility determination. Also, please read what factors would weigh heavily against a determination that an alien is likely to become a public charge. For example, you will not be categorized as a public charge if your financial assets, resources and support are at least 250 percent of the Federal Poverty Guidelines for a household of your household size or you are authorized to work and are currently employed with an annual income of at least 250 percent of the Federal Poverty Guidelines for a household of your household size.

Lynne Feldman

Lynne Feldman

Find an EB-5 Visa Lawyer: Immigration Attorney
Answered on

You should be fine. Nothing is in effect now just proposed.

DISCLAIMER: the information found on this website is intended to be general information; it is not legal or financial advice. Specific legal or financial advice can only be given by a licensed professional with full knowledge of all the facts and circumstances of your particular situation. You should seek consultation with legal, immigration, and financial experts prior to participating in the EB-5 program. Posting a question on this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. All questions you post will be available to the public: do not include confidential information in your question.